A Cautionary Tale About Online Reviews

Business, Property Management, Sales,  Principals,  Property Managers,  Salespeople

Online tasking platform Service Seeking recently landed itself in hot water with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) for its misleading customer review system. The site was hit with a $600,000 penalty by the Federal Court last month and was ordered to publically display its wrongdoings with a correction notice to be featured prominently on its website and app for 60 days: ACCC v Service Seeking Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1040.

Background

Service Seeking operates as an online platform which connects businesses with customers seeking assistance. Businesses offering a wide range of services can create a business profile on the site and customers can post jobs and receive quotes from businesses in their area.

Platforms such as Service Seeking rely heavily on online reviews. Customers undoubtedly use reviews to compare services and to make informed decisions when selecting a service provider. The reviews are a prominent feature of the business’ profile and the overall star rating is displayed in the search results. The business with the best overall star rating is displayed first in the searches.

From July 2016 to November 2018, Service Seeking gave businesses the option to use its “Fast Feedback” system. After a job was completed, businesses had the option to use Fast Feedback to gain a customer review. Businesses were able formulate a review and send it to the customer for confirmation. A business could select from a number of feedback options: that the job was completed “on time”, “on budget”, “to a professional standard”, or “with good communication”. A star rating out of five could also be chosen.

The site would then automatically generate an online review and send it to the customer’s email address. The customer had the option to agree to publish the review or reject the review and write their own. If the customer did not take any action within 42 to 96 hours of receiving the email, then the review and star rating would be automatically posted on the business’s profile.

The “Fast Feedback” feature was used to create about 21,000 reviews between July 2016 and November 2018. Approximately 80% of the reviews were published by default, meaning the reviews were automatically published without customer input.

The ACCC commenced proceedings against Service Seeking in the Federal Court in relation to its online reviews. The ACCC alleged that Service Seeking had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and false or misleading representations, in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law, which is found at Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the ACL).

In particular, it was alleged that Service Seeking had contravened section 29(1)(e ) of the ACL. This section states, inter alia:

Section 29: False or misleading representations about goods or services

A person must not, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services or in connection with the promotion by any means of the supply or use of goods or services:

(f) make a false or misleading representation concerning:

  • a testimonial by any person; or
  • (ii) a representation that purports to be such a testimonial; relating to goods or services; …

The Federal Court’s decision

Service Seeking admitted liability for the contraventions and the parties filed a statement of agreed facts and a minute of consent orders to determine the proceeding.

Essentially, Service Seeking accepted that the automatically generated reviews had the effect of purporting to be testimonials by the customers themselves. It also accepted that by allowing the publication of the reviews, it engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, as well as conduct that was likely to mislead the public as to the nature, characteristics and the suitability of the services of the businesses on the website.

The Court found that the Fast Feedback system was harmful for a number of reasons. Primarily, it deprived potential customers of an opportunity to accurately compare services provided by the businesses on the website. It also unfairly disadvantaged businesses who did not use Fast Feedback and whose profiles only contained genuine customer reviews.

In his judgment, Justice Jackson said:

“Service Seeking engaged in a systematic course of conduct for the self-interested purpose of increasing the attractiveness of its website to businesses and consumers in a manner which it must have known would give rise to numerous instances of misleading conduct. This was an abuse of the trust that customers can be inferred to have placed in the site.”

The Court ordered that Service Seeking:

  • Be restrained for a period of three years from publishing any review without the express written consent of the customer;
  • Pay a pecuniary penalty of $600,000 for breaches of the ACL;
  • Publish a corrective notice on the homepage of its website and app setting out its conduct and the finding of the Court; and
  • Establish and implement a compliance program.

Service Seeking was also ordered to pay the ACCC’s costs in the sum of $40,000.

a lesson on online reviews and testimonials for real estate professionals

Online reviews and testimonials from clients are often used by agents to promote their services in order to attract listings and potential clients. As this case clearly demonstrates, there are significant penalties which may apply if it transpires that a review is not genuine or it does not accurately reflect the views of the person who provided it.

Agents should also bear in mind that Article 9(a) of the REIQ Standards of Business Practice provides that members must not make false or misleading representations or statements about properties or businesses, or engage in any conduct which is likely to mislead or deceive.

Enrol Today

Here’s what others have to say

Welcoming and friendly staff, always available to support their members. The Property Management Support Team is particularly helpful. Well worth the subscription fees just to have access to advice from these experienced practitioners.
Laura Valenti
Laura Valenti
21:29 16 Jun 18
Recently I completed the Real Estate Licensing course at REIQ and was blown away by the help and support provided by Ms. Connie McKee who is a trainer at REIQ. Connie is very professional and has years of knowledge and work experience in the Real Estate Industry.I am glad I chose REIQ as my pathway into the Real Estate Industry.
Kaizan Irani
Kaizan Irani
00:23 30 May 19
I would like to share with you our experience that we have recently had through the REIQ Professional Development Team.We have had an awesome start to 2020 thanks to the great service provided by the REIQ Professional Development Team. Congratulations to Liz who started and finished her Certificate of Registration Course with the REIQ in December 2019. She loved the training, particularly the fact the trainers are experienced and still walk the talk and are active in real estate. Fast turnaround for marking of the assessments with help on hand by way of tutoring if needed meant she could get the Application to Office of Fair Trading for her registration happening quickly. We are thrilled, from start to finish with the course and application to Fair Trading she had her Certificate of Registration within 5 weeks. Really impressed with the training, help and support team REIQ gave Liz and the quick processing time by the Office of Fair Trading.We also regularly use the Property Management Support Service and General Agency Advice Service and believe it offers great value for our membership. The PMSS team provide practical advice by practising property management professionals who can relate to the everyday challenges property managers face.Keep up the good work Team REIQ,
RE/MAX Ignite
RE/MAX Ignite
05:56 21 Jan 20
Had Melissa Sullivan conducting the sales registration course for the past two days I have to say I think this woman is inspiring she kept the class focused and engaged throughout the two days. I dont normally complete surveys but felt that I wanted to share that this lady has inspired me to give sales ago and I never thought i would say that as i have been a PM and honestly never thought I could see myself as a sales agent... Thanks Mel for such a great two days
Karen Riddell
Karen Riddell
07:04 03 Aug 17
I found the REIQ Real Estate Licence Online Training Course was very good, easy to access, with brilliant course materials to read and assignments that really checked on your understanding of the details of every aspect of real estate practise. I enjoyed the course even though it took a few months due to working full time and found the support of the trainers and assessors very helpful and encouraging. Thanks REIQ Training team for helping me through!
Lindy Lear
Lindy Lear
10:47 18 Oct 20
I cannot recommend REIQ enough. The training, environment & staff were beyond my expectations. A special mention for Rachael who is a trainer at REIQ. Rachael knows her stuff. Her knowledge of the industry and style of delivery helped me get across the line and score my dream job.
Paul Conway
Paul Conway
05:11 15 Jan 20
Liam Hanlon
Liam Hanlon
12:06 05 Sep 17
Michelle Wright
Michelle Wright
04:07 26 Feb 18
Adam Milton
Adam Milton
01:52 22 Nov 17
Good course. Materials and tools given to finish the course easily. Was no problem to finish. Support is there if needed it.
Jade Dodds
Jade Dodds
09:11 09 Oct 20
Jacqui McKeering
Jacqui McKeering
02:01 08 Mar 18
Tina Nenadic
Tina Nenadic
12:57 02 Mar 18
Very impressed with the trainers that I have had for the past 3 days. Each individual trainer was very helpful and made sure that everyone in the class understood everything before we progressed through the modules.
Shannon Goldsworthy
Shannon Goldsworthy
04:34 23 Oct 19
Great staff that are always helpful.
Kensington Ràpoza
Kensington Ràpoza
11:20 28 Dec 19
Katie Cotton
Katie Cotton
10:04 31 Oct 17
Just done two days interactive training with Melissa Sullivan. Sensational! Such a great presenter and electric delivery of material. Quick paced and hands-on!Very glad to have been in this class!!! Awesome
Miles Griffiths
Miles Griffiths
07:01 26 Jun 18
Great training course was very informative. I feel I gained lots of knowledge and there is a lot of support from the REIQ team online, via phone and in person and am looking forward to starting my career in the real estate industry!
Laura Stills
Laura Stills
08:14 22 Oct 20
Great friendly environment
David Priest
David Priest
22:47 19 Nov 19
Blake Richard
Blake Richard
01:34 05 Mar 18
Proud to be a member of such a prestigious organisation. Thank You for the support 🏡
Jamie Smith
Jamie Smith
07:28 07 Mar 18
Gerry MacKenzie
Gerry MacKenzie
06:53 12 Oct 20
In February I decided to take steps to buy management rights to a unit complex. As I have not studied for some time I chose REIQ to do my RLA course. Initially I didn’t engage the help through student support but it came to a point I needed some assistance. Selina Randall and Connie McKee were wonderful help. I personally feel they went over and beyond to help me complete the course and enable me to follow through with final settlement of the new business in just a few weeks Thank you so very much ladies. You were both amazing
Irmy Thomas
Irmy Thomas
06:35 18 Jun 21
Haydn Denovan
Haydn Denovan
02:51 20 Mar 18
Jodie was an amazing help throughout the training. We had a few technical issues and I knew that I could call and get it sorted alongside her. She was always supportive and no task was ever a bother for her. Thanks again Jodie !!
Kirsty Bohn
Kirsty Bohn
04:40 30 Jun 21
I contacted REIQ, as I wanted to upgrade my real estate licence to a full licence. I have now completed the necessary upgrade and I just wanted to thank all the staff and trainers who were my guides during this time. Particular mention to Rachael Wilschefski who did everything she could to help me and was a joy to talk to, Trudi Fleet was a fantastic support to me and a big thank you to the assessing team. If anyone is considering using REIQ to get their licence or upgrade, I highly recommend using REIQ. Once again, thank you. Helen Knight
Helen Knight
Helen Knight
00:31 05 Mar 21
I wasnt sure that I would get through the Agents and Licence course with everything I had on, made an attempt a year ago with another provider that went totally pear shaped but the REIQ course is structured in a way that made sense. While all of their trainers are experts in their field, they offer onsite student support on Tuesdays with Rachel providing the right advice and reassurance to get you there, even if you havent studied for a while. If you've ever wanted a career in Real Estate this is where you get started!
Lynette Nitson
Lynette Nitson
01:48 13 Jan 20
Recently completed my Licence course and thoroughly enjoyed the in-class tutorials taught by highly professional trainers with many years of industry experiences. The student support that is available every Tuesday is an extremely helpful resource, again with very experienced trainers to ensure you get the right advice the first time. REIQ has really structured the entire full Licence course end to end thoughtfully, especially when you’re new to this industry. Highly recommended!
Julian Phua
Julian Phua
07:01 02 Oct 19
Jason Bond
Jason Bond
10:29 19 Jun 18
Helpful staff. Useful networking events and training videos.
Eagle Real Estate
Eagle Real Estate
02:27 25 Jul 18

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Subscribe